Many enterprises have tried employing "free" software
like Samba and even some vendors like SGI have tried
to incorporate it into a "product"; hopefully some
of these folks on this list will respond to your request but
from working with "some" of these enterprises I can tell
you from experience that Samba neither "scales" in
the enterprise nor does it perform beyond about 75
clients doing useful work in a medium to large
domain structure..it also is not an easy beast to
administer( as explained to me be by several admins);
it is "free" , however...
Netapp glues the MS smb(cifs) code into our microkernel at the
protocol level; Samba and other bolt-ons sit above kernel
space as any other user app would and is subject to the
context switching and shufflings that go on in a general purpose
server; this (primarily) is why the Netapp CIFS solution both scales
well and performs well as we add hundreds of users(see our Netbench
results, for example); this is why the solution is not "free"
-----Original Message-----
From: Philip Thomas [mailto:thomas@act.sps.mot.com]
Sent: Friday, May 26, 2000 11:03 PM
To: toasters(a)mathworks.com
Subject: Samba Vs CIFFS
Hi,
Why should some one pay good money to buy CIFFS license from NetApp
when apparently the similar functionality is available "free", Samba?
I am hoping folks out there, with experience in both products would
be willing to share their knowledge as much their internal policy allows.
I am specifically looking for pros and cons with respect to
(a) performance (what ever than means)
(b) scalibility (500+ users)
(c) reliability
(d) functionality
(e) coexistence with Windows Terminal Server
(f) 'cost' (not just dollars)
(g) administration
(h) interaction or lack of it with commercial apps
...any thing else ??
Perhaps this list is biased to CIFFS, by definition of the mailing list. But I
have seen folks willing to speak out in the past.
[BTW, please don't shoot the messenger:-)]
Thanks.
Philip Thomas
Motorola - DDL-ITG, M/S M360
2200 W. Broadway Rd
Mesa, AZ 85202
rxjs80(a)email.sps.mot.com
(480) 655-3678
(480) 655-3881 (fax)