Greg,
I will take a crack at answering this for you as a "guy in the know..".
First things first; you are not the first to bring this up. As you may or may not know, NetApp wrote a protocol several years ago called NDMP which stands for Network Data Management Protocol, which allows for a "standard" that controls remote tape devices, storage pools, etc. Most every backup vendor signed on to support the protocol (Veritas, Intelliguard, BudTool, Seagate, CommVault, etc.) except Legato, who maintained the "superiority" of their proprietary system. There have been a large number of VERY big NetApp installs that have been pushing Legato to provide native NetApp or they would switch to another product.
This led to the co-development of a Java-based Legato Networker client that will run directly on the Filer. The expected shipping date of this product is Q2/99. This product will be distributed, supported (and presumably sold) directly by Legato.
But wait!! Things get EVEN better! On 1/28/99, Legato announced that they were acquiring Intelliguard Software:
http://www.legato.com/press/PR200.html
One of the main reasons cited for buying Intelliguard was the NDMP technology.
EVEN BETTER!!!!!!!!! On 2/2/99, Legato announced that all Networker products will be NDMP compliant in Q3/99:
http://www.legato.com/press/PR209.html
With a big sigh of relief and a smile on their faces, NetApp customers and employees could give a hearty YAHOO!!!
Now, the question was asked about keeping the CIFS attributes during backup; both of the methods above will allow this to happen. In current environments, backups need to be done by an NT machine running Networker, OR having a UNIX Networker server that backs up an NT machine with the Filer mounted on it.
I hope that this helps.
Regards, Matt
Matt Whitman - Consulting Systems Engineer Network Appliance, Inc. www.netapp.com 2350 Mission College Blvd. Suite 900 Santa Clara, CA 95054 (408)367-3000 Corporate
mattw@netapp.com - E-mail (408)987-5365 - Direct Dial (408)987-5364 - Fax
-----Original Message----- From: Gregory M. Paris [mailto:paris@bose.com] Sent: Friday, March 05, 1999 12:26 PM To: toasters@mathworks.com Cc: paris@bose.com Subject: Legato Networker backups
Dear Toasters,
This is along the lines of the "Future Newbie" thread, though I'm not new to NetApp boxes. I am looking to get our first here at this company. We use Legato Networker to backup our Engineering systems, which I support. (We use HP's Omniback and a StorageTek tape library for our business systems, but that's another post....) The problem is, I'm not clear on how I'll backup an F740 (~180 GB) using Networker.
I've read the "How to Integrate..." white paper on the NetApp site. I've read the ancient "Backing Up NetApp..." on the Legato site. Neither of those seem to address our situation: Networker server running on Solaris; NetApp server with NFS and CIFS. How do I? I can connect a Quantum DLT stacker to the NetApp, but can I make Legato use it? If not, how do I backup over the network, given that I want to preserve NT ACLs? The "How to Integrate..." document shows how to do this when Networker runs on an NT machine, but we have it on UNIX.
I'm looking for a definitive answer, on the order of, "We do it here and it works great!" (along with the how-to, of course). I'm bucking the prevailing winds in trying to bring in a NetApp. Tiny issues like, "No proven way to back it up," could result in me supporting a new HP or Sun server. (Not that I don't use their equipment already, but the combination of RAID and NFS+CIFS is too much complexity on UNIX servers, IMHO.) All help is appreciated.
Greg
Whitman, Matthew wrote:
Now, the question was asked about keeping the CIFS attributes during backup; both of the methods above will allow this to happen. In current environments, backups need to be done by an NT machine running Networker, OR having a UNIX Networker server that backs up an NT machine with the Filer mounted on it.
I'd like to just add a 'small' addition to the backup debate. With BudTool, backups are done locally on the machine being backed up itself using the local dump/restore command using NDMP, it doesn't use any proprietary backup data streams. This is great for quick restores in the event of a true disaster. If the NetApp 'blows up' with (or without) BudTool you can restore the data to a Solaris box as the dump format for Solaris and OnTap are (almost) the same.
However, and I can't comment on NetWorker, using ACLs the dump on the NetApp does an extra sixth pass to backup the ACLs (please correct me if I am wrong here). If there was a true disaster that meant restoring data quickly, but no NetApp was available, (or if a tape was taken to another site for restoring) then the data can still be restored instantly back to any solaris box using standard UNIX (mt ufsrestore), however ufsrestore on Solaris does not have this sixth pass so the ACLs would be lost. Does Networker handle this in it's proprietary format? Have I missed something here?
There is nothing fantastic about backup on a NetApp really, the snapshot is a great facility...it's the restoring ability you need to consider. Networker's disaster recovery is pretty hideous...BudTool's is simple, but not being able to restore the ACLs is not a nice prospect for some people. Whatever happens with Networker/BudTool will this restoring flexibility be lost? Or would it be possible for the dump command on the NetApp to somehow stay compatible with the dump formats on other UNIX boxes and 'integrate' this sixth pass in the five that a normal dump does keeping the compatibility? If Legato implement NDMP does that mean they have to use the dump command on the NetApp or can they use NDMP and still stay proprietary?