This is actually a request/question for netapp, but I'm hoping
to generate a few "me too"'s from the list.
We're a large (1200 systems) ATM shop. For various reasons, we're
using Fore SPANS signalling, and will be for awhile. The move to
standards-based ATM is going to be ugly, and we (and the standards)
aren't quite ready yet.
NetApp supports SPANS ATM, using Fore's PCI card and a port of the
SPANS protocol engine in their ATM drivers. This is good.
But, there are two features of Fore SPANS that NetApp doesn't support,
that we rely on. This message is a request to NetApp to consider adding
support for these two features:
1. load balancing. Fore SPANS on other platforms (IRIX, Solaris) provides
interface aggregation such that multiple ATM interfaces on the same
host are used equally. This is connection-based load balancing, in that
new connections are assigned round-robin to all the interfaces in a
given load balance group, on a given machine.
On some platforms, all interfaces in a given system can have the same IP
address, which simplifies management, and means there is one "view"
of a multi-interface machine from the outside. Routing gets simpler, too.
We can get some balancing using static routing configuations that spreads
the load over all the interfaces in a system, but it's not quite the same.
Plus, support for load balancing may help provide support for:
2. fail over. If an interface, or switch fabric, or other component fails,
Fore SPANS will fail an interface, and all the connections will be
re-established on the other available interfaces. Our core switch
architecture is such that each server has multiple ATM "feet", in
different switches and backplanes, so we've got fault tolerance with
automatic failover when somthing in the network path croaks.
It's the failover that we're most interested in, for the fault tolerance
and redundancy reasons. load balancing makes administration easier, and
helps us better utilize the switch architecture we have in place.
So, NetApp, what are the chances of getting SPANS fail over and load balancing
in your ATM implementation?
-Skottie
--
-----
Scott Miller | Walt Disney Feature Animation
skottie(a)fa.disney.com | Digital Studio Technology